Foreign Sanctions and Contract Non-Performance: Two Routes Under China’s Anti-Foreign Sanctions Law
What remedies are available when a foreign counterparty withholds payment or refuses delivery on sanctions grounds?
In Nanjing, a Chinese offshore engineering company brought a statutory tort claim after a European counterparty withheld more than USD 11.86 million in shipbuilding payments. The parties settled through court mediation. In Shanghai, a shipper sued for breach of a carriage contract, and the court applied Article 12 of China’s Anti-Foreign Sanctions Law as an overriding mandatory rule to reject the carrier’s sanctions defence. The two cases show why the cause of action matters.
1. Nanjing: Vessel Arrest, Security and SettlementPART 01 · THE STATUTORY TORT ROUTE
The subcontract and withheld payment
On 7 September 2023, a Chinese offshore engineering company entered into a shipbuilding subcontract worth approximately USD 19.45 million with a European marine equipment company. It agreed to construct modules for a floating production, storage and offloading vessel (FPSO). The Chinese contractor completed its contractual module work by 7 June 2024. The vessel was in Nantong, Jiangsu.
On 12 June 2024, a third country designated the Chinese contractor under its sanctions regime. The European company cited that country’s executive order, suspended payment of the outstanding balance of more than USD 11.86 million and cut off communications.
Pre-action arrest and security for release
On 18 September 2024, the Nanjing Maritime Court ordered the vessel’s pre-action arrest. The order prevented the vessel from leaving port or departing China while allowing conversion work to continue in place. That arrangement preserved security for the maritime claim while limiting disruption to the project.
On 11 October 2024, the contractor brought an Article 12 tort action seeking cessation of the alleged infringement and compensation for the unpaid balance, interest and related losses. The claim exceeded RMB 86 million. The European company then applied to the sanctioning country for a payment licence and posted RMB 99.743 million in security to obtain release of the vessel. The application for a licence should be distinguished from the posting of security and from any decision to grant a licence.
Court mediation and recovery
During the period for filing a defence, the court explained the potential consequences under Chinese law of implementing or assisting in the implementation of foreign unilateral sanctions. The parties requested court mediation and reached a settlement within 39 days of filing. On 19 November 2024, the court issued a civil mediation statement recording the settlement. On the contractor’s application, the court disbursed the settlement amount from the release security through enforcement proceedings. The court reported recovery of more than RMB 84 million. The parties agreed that disputes arising from the settlement would be subject to Chinese law and the jurisdiction of the Nanjing Maritime Court.
2. Shanghai: Sanctions as a Defence to Breach of ContractPART 02 · OVERRIDING MANDATORY RULES
Refusal to issue a bill of lading or deliver cargo
Case No. 6 in the Supreme People’s Court’s 2025 maritime case collection, released on 24 June 2026, concerned a Hong Kong shipper and a Singapore carrier. In October 2022, the shipper booked carriage of electronic goods worth more than RMB 4.99 million from Shanghai to Manzanillo, Panama. After receiving and loading the cargo, the carrier refused to issue the bill of lading and, after arrival, refused delivery at the destination port, citing a foreign sanctions designation against the shipper.
The Shanghai Maritime Court issued a maritime injunction requiring the carrier to issue the bill of lading. The carrier complied with that order but returned the cargo to Shanghai without authorisation while the injunction proceedings were ongoing. The shipper brought a contract claim, and the carrier counterclaimed for container detention charges.
Why a Singapore law clause did not exclude Article 12
According to the published case commentary from the Shanghai High People’s Court, the reverse-side terms of the bill of lading selected Singapore law. The carrier argued that its response to sanctions exposure did not constitute a breach. The maritime court held that refusing delivery and returning the cargo without authorisation amounted to a fundamental breach.
Article 4 of the Law of the People’s Republic of China on the Application of Laws to Foreign-Related Civil Relations provides for direct application of Chinese mandatory provisions to covered foreign-related civil relations. The court applied Article 12 of the Anti-Foreign Sanctions Law on that basis. It characterised the refusal to perform as assistance in implementing discriminatory restrictive measures against a Chinese enterprise and held that this conduct could not excuse the breach or reduce the carrier’s liability.
The court awarded more than RMB 4.99 million in damages for the cargo loss, plus interest, and dismissed the carrier’s counterclaim in full. No party appealed, and the judgment took legal effect. Published judicial commentary describes it as the first judgment to clarify the mandatory application of Article 12. Direct application means that a choice of foreign law cannot displace the Chinese mandatory rule on the issue it governs. It does not invalidate the entire choice-of-law clause or dispose of every foreign sanctions issue without further analysis.
3. Article 12: Two Legal RoutesPART 03 · CAUSE OF ACTION AND FORUM
Different functions of the two paragraphs
Paragraph 1: Article 12 prohibits organisations and individuals from implementing or assisting in the implementation of discriminatory restrictive measures taken by foreign states against Chinese citizens or organisations.
Paragraph 2: Where a violation infringes their lawful rights and interests, affected Chinese citizens or organisations may sue in a people’s court for cessation of the infringement and compensation for losses.
Article 12, Anti-Foreign Sanctions Law · English summary of the Chinese text| Issue | Nanjing | Shanghai |
|---|---|---|
| Cause of action | Statutory tort claim under Article 12(2) | Breach of a contract for carriage of goods by sea |
| Role of Article 12 | Direct basis for seeking cessation and damages | Article 12(1) applied through Article 4 to defeat the carrier’s sanctions defence |
| Disposition | Court-mediated settlement; settlement sum paid out of release security through enforcement | Judgment on the merits; damages and interest awarded, counterclaim dismissed |
What must a claimant establish under Article 12?
First, identify the foreign measure. Examine its legal character, target, scope and connection to the Chinese party. Foreign sanctions, export controls and general compliance requirements do not all fall within Article 12.
Second, identify the conduct. Withholding payment, stopping a transaction or imposing new conditions may amount to implementation or assistance. The evidence should establish the link to the discriminatory restrictive measure and address any independent, legitimate explanation for the conduct.
Third, establish infringement and the elements of the remedy sought. A damages claim calls for analysis of loss and causation. A claim for cessation focuses on the conduct that needs to be stopped.
Article 12 does not prescribe a special standard of fault or allocation of the burden of proof. Related scholarship proposes a rebuttable presumption of fault to reduce the claimant’s evidentiary burden, under which the defendant could seek to justify its conduct after a prima facie showing. This is a proposed reform. The Nanjing settlement did not resolve fault, the burden of proof or the other disputed elements of liability.
Does an Article 12 tort claim displace a contractual arbitration clause?
A published study by a Nanjing Maritime Court judge who participated in the case reports that the subcontract provided for arbitration administered by the London Court of International Arbitration (LCIA) and selected English law. After receiving the court papers, the European company did not invoke the arbitration agreement to contest the court’s jurisdiction and ultimately participated in court mediation.
Interim relief and jurisdiction over the merits are separate. Under Articles 13 and 14 of the Special Maritime Procedure Law, a claimant may seek pre-action preservation from the maritime court where the property is located, and an arbitration or jurisdiction agreement does not bar such preservation. The grant of arrest does not itself confer jurisdiction over the underlying dispute. Article 19 preserves the effect of applicable jurisdiction and arbitration agreements on subsequent proceedings in the circumstances it addresses.
The same study argues that Article 12 serves public interests in sovereignty, security and development, and that its statutory tort remedy should therefore be reserved to Chinese courts, notwithstanding the contractual arbitration clause. The study separately identifies waiver as a possible explanation for the court proceeding in this particular case, given the defendant’s failure to object and its participation. These are scholarly analyses, not holdings from a contested jurisdiction ruling.
Overriding mandatory rules and arbitrability answer different questions. Article 12 expressly provides access to a people’s court, but does not expressly make every such dispute non-arbitrable or invalidate all related arbitration agreements. A court faced with a timely objection would still need to consider the scope and validity of the agreement, whether the particular statutory tort claim falls within it, and whether the dispute is arbitrable. The Nanjing settlement does not resolve those issues.
4. ConclusionPART 04 · PRACTICAL IMPLICATIONS
In Nanjing, Article 12(2) supplied the basis for seeking tort relief, and mediation resolved the dispute. In Shanghai, the shipper’s claim sounded in contract; Article 12(1), applied through China’s conflict-of-laws rules, governed the carrier’s sanctions defence, and the court entered judgment on the merits.
When a counterparty cites sanctions to withhold payment or delivery, assess the cause of action, the specific foreign measure, any overriding mandatory rule and the agreed dispute resolution mechanism separately. Preserve the contract, the designation and relevant communications before selecting the remedy and forum.
Legislation and Case Materials
- Anti-Foreign Sanctions Law of the People’s Republic of China, Article 12.
- Provisions on Implementing the Anti-Foreign Sanctions Law, State Council Order No. 803 (2025).
- Regulations of the People’s Republic of China on Countering Improper Foreign Extraterritorial Jurisdiction, State Council Order No. 835 (2026).
- Rules on Counteracting Unjustified Extraterritorial Application of Foreign Legislation and Other Measures, Ministry of Commerce Order No. 1 (2021).
- Law on the Application of Laws to Foreign-Related Civil Relations, Article 4; Special Maritime Procedure Law, Articles 13, 14 and 19.
- Nanjing Maritime Court: report on the first anti-foreign-sanctions tort action; report on the settlement and recovery; People’s Courts Case Database, entry No. 2025-10-6-504-001.
- Supreme People’s Court: 2025 Typical Maritime Adjudication Cases, Case No. 6, released on 24 June 2026; published judicial commentary on the bill of lading and the judgment.
The implementing provisions, 2026 regulations and 2021 ministry rules are listed for context. They are distinct instruments; the two cases discussed here concern Article 12 of the 2021 statute.
Related Research
- Related research on private remedies under China’s Anti-Foreign Sanctions Law (2025).
- Related research on Article 12 tort actions and contractual arbitration clauses (2025, Issue 7, pp. 92–106), by a judge who participated in the Nanjing case.
Dealing with a sanctions-related refusal to perform?
We advise on cross-border contract disputes, sanctions-related defences, interim relief and dispute resolution strategy.
Request a consultation

